Studies in the Spotlight
BiKS: Educational Processes, Competence Development and Selection Decisions in Preschool and School Age đź”—
This study by Kretschmann and colleagues (2019) examines how repeating a school year affects the motivation of retained students in Germany, where grade retention remains common but controversial and prior research has produced mixed results. Unlike earlier work, the authors used longitudinal data from the BiKS 8-14 study and propensity score matching to compare retained students with similar peers who were promoted, tracking them over three years of secondary school. They found that effects appear even before the retention occurs: retained students showed lower academic self-concept and less interest in German and math, plus a decline in learning motivation shortly before being held back. These effects were mostly temporary but sometimes persisted for one or two years, and overall the findings speak against the practice of grade retention.
For a more in-depth discussion of these observations and the theoretical background, as well as a very detailed description of the methodological approach, we recommend the full text of the article: Kretschmann, J., Vock, M., Lüdtke, O., Jansen, M., & Gronostaj, A. (2019). Effects of grade retention on students’ motivation: A longitudinal study over 3 years of secondary school. Journal of Educational Psychology, 111(8), 1432–1446. https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000353
This study by Helbig and Morar (2018) asks whether Boudon’s model of primary and secondary origin effects needs to be extended by a tertiary effect, meaning socially unequal grading that is independent of students’ actual competencies. Using multilevel regressions on several datasets (BiKS 8-14, TIMSS 2011, IQB National Assessment Study 2011, and ELEMENT), they examined whether psychological traits such as effort explain why grades differ by socioeconomic background at the end of primary school. Students’ and parents’ self-assessments of these traits influenced grades but explained little of the grading bias. In contrast, teachers’ assessments of the same traits strongly affected grades and varied with family background, suggesting that teachers expect more favorable traits from children of highly educated parents and reward this in their grading, with an additional interaction between federal state and teachers’ perception of parental support.
For a detailed discussion of this effect and the other background information, findings, and implications, please refer to the full text of the article: Helbig, M. & Morar, T. (2018). Why Teachers Assign Socially Unequal Grades. A Case for Establishing Tertiary Origin Effects in the Model of Primary and Secondary Effects of Educational Research. International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 17(7), 1–25.https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.17.7.1
Oppermann and Lazarides (2021) used longitudinal data from the BiKS 8-14 study to examine how elementary school teachers’ self-efficacy relates to students’ perceived support and their interest in mathematics at the end of primary school. Multilevel structural equation models showed that teachers’ self-efficacy positively predicted the support students perceived, which in turn positively influenced their math interest. However, there was no significant direct or indirect effect of teacher self-efficacy on math interest itself. The authors conclude that supportive teacher behavior is the key mechanism through which positive teacher effects can unfold.
You can read about how to explain these findings and what they mean for research and practice here: Oppermann, E. & Lazarides, R. (2021). Elementary school teachers' self-efficacy, student-perceived support, and students’ interest in mathematics. Teaching and Teacher Education, 103(6).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2021.103351
Schmerse (2020) used data from the BiKS 3-10 study to examine how the quality of the child-teacher relationship in preschool relates to children's later math and reading achievement in second grade. Using moderated mediation analyses, he tested the roles of motivational characteristics, family socioeconomic status, and further control variables. The results show that positive attitudes toward learning and achievement can already be fostered in preschool, which in turn supports later achievement. The study also looks at what this means for children from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, with SES acting as a moderator.
You can read about what this finding means for children from lower socioeconomic backgrounds in the study: Schmerse, D. (2020). Preschool Quality Effects on Learning Behavior and Later Achievement in Germany: Moderation by Socioeconomic Status. Child Development, 91: 2237-2254.
https://doi.org/10.1111/cdev.13357
Hürlimann, Lüdtke, and Schmerse (2025) used integrative data analysis of six German longitudinal studies, covering over 15,000 children in more than 2,500 preschool and primary school classes, to examine whether a group’s average language skills influence individual children’s language development. Identical multilevel models were estimated for each study and then combined meta-analytically, allowing for a systematic check of differences between studies. There was no general main effect, meaning children overall did not benefit from learning alongside linguistically stronger peers. However, children with lower initial language skills benefited clearly more, while those with average or high skills showed no effect, pointing to compensatory effects. The authors conclude that purposefully composed learning groups could help reduce language disparities, and that integrative analyses across studies offer great potential for secondary research.
You can find the full article here: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2026-54793-001
Aldrup, Klusmann, and Lüdtke (2019) used longitudinal data from the BiKS 8-14 study to examine how students’ math anxiety relates to their achievement development in lower secondary school. They also tested whether teachers’ sensitivity in recognizing students’ academic problems and need for emotional support changes this relationship. Cross-lagged panel analyses revealed reciprocal negative associations between math anxiety (especially worry) and achievement. High teacher sensitivity can additionally contribute to lower math anxiety among students.
You can read more about the findings here: Aldrup, K., Klusmann, U., & Lüdtke, O. (2019). Reciprocal associations between students’ mathematics anxiety and achievement: Can teacher sensitivity make a difference? Journal of Educational Psychology.https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000398
BiSpra: Academic Language Competencies đź”—
Hürlimann, Lüdtke, and Schmerse (2025) used integrative data analysis of six German longitudinal studies, covering over 15,000 children in more than 2,500 preschool and primary school classes, to examine whether a group’s average language skills influence individual children’s language development. Identical multilevel models were estimated for each study and then combined meta-analytically, allowing for a systematic check of differences between studies. There was no general main effect, meaning children overall did not benefit from learning alongside linguistically stronger peers. However, children with lower initial language skills benefited clearly more, while those with average or high skills showed no effect, pointing to compensatory effects. The authors conclude that purposefully composed learning groups could help reduce language disparities, and that integrative analyses across studies offer great potential for secondary research.
You can find the full article here: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2026-54793-001
ELEMENT: Survey of Reading and Mathematics Comprehension đź”—
This study by Helbig and Morar (2018) asks whether Boudon’s model of primary and secondary origin effects needs to be extended by a tertiary effect, meaning socially unequal grading that is independent of students’ actual competencies. Using multilevel regressions on several datasets (BiKS 8-14, TIMSS 2011, IQB National Assessment Study 2011, and ELEMENT), they examined whether psychological traits such as effort explain why grades differ by socioeconomic background at the end of primary school. Students’ and parents’ self-assessments of these traits influenced grades but explained little of the grading bias. In contrast, teachers’ assessments of the same traits strongly affected grades and varied with family background, suggesting that teachers expect more favorable traits from children of highly educated parents and reward this in their grading, with an additional interaction between federal state and teachers’ perception of parental support.
For a detailed discussion of this effect and the other background information, findings, and implications, please refer to the full text of the article: Helbig, M. & Morar, T. (2018). Why Teachers Assign Socially Unequal Grades. A Case for Establishing Tertiary Origin Effects in the Model of Primary and Secondary Effects of Educational Research. International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 17(7), 1–25.https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.17.7.1
Wolff and colleagues (2018) combined data from the longitudinal ELEMENT study with their own data collections to examine how three comparison processes jointly shape students' academic self-concept, using structural equation and multilevel models. They found that students in higher-achieving classes reported lower self-concepts (social comparisons), and that achievement in a subject was positively related to self-concept in that subject but negatively related to self-concept in other subjects (dimensional comparisons). Achievement gains also increased academic self-concept (temporal comparisons). Together, the findings support the 2I/E model, which integrates temporal comparisons into the internal/external frame of reference model.
To learn which of these comparison processes has the strongest influence on self-concept and how the similarity between school subjects relates to dimensional comparisons, see: Wolff, F., Nagy, G., Retelsdorf, J., Helm, F., Köller, O., & Möller, J. (2018). The 2I/E model: Integrating temporal comparisons into the internal/external frame of reference model. Journal of Educational Psychology. Advance online publication. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/edu0000319
Kretschmann and colleagues (2016) used data from the longitudinal ELEMENT study, which includes questionnaire and competence data from about 5,000 students across three grade levels as well as their parents and teachers, to examine how skipping a grade in elementary school affects children's motivation and socio-emotional development. Using propensity score matching, they compared accelerated children with similar peers who had comparable learning prerequisites and background characteristics. Skipping a grade had no effect on self-reported school satisfaction but was associated with lower self-reported social integration. The study also investigates effects on academic self-concept and school anxiety, with a particular focus on gender differences.
To find out to what extent skipping a grade affected academic self-concept and school anxiety—and whether gender differences were found—read the article below: Kretschmann, J., Vock, M., Lüdtke, O., & Gronostaj, A. (2016). Skipping to the bigger pond: Examining gender differences in students’ psychosocial development after early acceleration. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 46, 195-207.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2016.06.001
Wolff and colleagues (2018) examined the simultaneous effects of social, temporal, and dimensional comparison processes on students' academic self-concept. Their analyses combined primary data from an experimental design with secondary data from the longitudinal ELEMENT study, illustrating how primary and large-scale assessment data can be integrated to answer a single research question. The results show that students use all three types of comparison (with classmates, with their own previous performance, and across school subjects) and integrate the resulting information when forming their ability self-perceptions. The study also looks at how downward versus upward social comparisons influence academic self-concept differently.
You can read about the extent to which downward and upward comparisons (e.g., with weaker or better classmates) differ in their impact on academic self-concept in the publication cited below: Wolff, F., Helm, F., Zimmermann, F., Nagy, G., & Möller, J. (2018). On the effects of social, temporal, and dimensional comparisons on academic self-concept. Journal of Educational Psychology. Advance online publication.http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/edu0000248
PIRLS: Progress in International Reading Literacy Study đź”—
RĂĽdiger, Jansen, and Kocaj examined how teacher-rated work and social behavior influence the subject grades of primary school children, and what role gender plays. Using secondary data from IGLU 2016 and TIMSS 2015, they tested whether teachers rate girls' and boys' behavior differently and whether these ratings affect grades in German and math, even when controlling for competencies. Girls' work and social behavior were consistently rated more positively, but only work behavior, not social behavior, influenced grades. Work behavior ratings mediated part of the gender differences in grades, fully in German and partially in math, showing how general behavioral judgments can spill over into subject-specific assessments. You can find the full article here:
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/10.1024/1010-0652/a000401
IQB National Assessment Study and IQB Trends in Student Achievement đź”—
KĂĽnstler-Sment, Kocaj, Lorenz, and Jansen (2023) used data from the IQB-Bildungstrends 2018, covering over 10,000 ninth-graders in 368 secondary schools, to examine whether students are more socially integrated in all-day schools than in half-day schools and what role participation in extracurricular activities plays. Social integration was measured through self-reports (e.g., school satisfaction, sense of belonging) as well as sociometric network measures at the classroom level (e.g., friendship and support among seatmates). Students in classes with higher participation in extracurricular activities reported stronger social relationships and greater school satisfaction, and social integration tended to be slightly higher in all-day schools, although these differences were small and became clear only when accounting for factors such as school type, migration background, and socioeconomic status. The findings suggest that what matters most is not the school format itself, but how often and how intensively students take part in shared activities.
You can find the full article here: https://doi.org/10.1024/1010-0652/a000370
Lorenz, Lenz, and Rjosk (2023) critically examined Hartmut Esser's Model of Ability Tracking (MoAbiT) by testing, with data from the IQB-Bildungstrends 2015 and 2018, whether strict ability tracking (e.g., through binding transition recommendations) leads to more cognitively homogeneous classes and whether such homogeneity is linked to higher achievement. They found that cognitive homogeneity differed only partially and minimally between strictly tracked and more liberal school systems, so the model's first assumption lacks sufficient support. Students in strictly tracked systems showed achievement advantages, but these cannot necessarily be attributed to tracking itself. Findings on homogenization were mixed: it appeared beneficial for students with high individual math skills but detrimental for those with low skills, which the authors attribute to possible peer effects.
For more exciting findings and a first-rate overview of the research on academic tracking, we recommend reading the full text of the study:
https://doi.org/10.1515/zfsoz-2023-2028
Kuhl, Kocaj, and Stanat (2022) used data from the IQB-Ländervergleich 2011, covering 25,168 students in 1,278 classes, to examine the consequences for students without special educational needs (SEN) of being taught together with students with SEN. They compared cognitive outcomes (reading and listening in German, math) and motivational and socio-emotional characteristics (e.g., enjoyment of learning) between students with and without SEN classmates, using multilevel analyses and differentiating by SEN focus (learning, language, emotional and social development). Overall, there were no significant differences in competencies or socio-emotional characteristics, suggesting that inclusive classes bring neither advantages nor disadvantages for students without SEN. However, the analyses by SEN focus indicated that including students with emotional and social development needs might be associated with slightly less favorable outcomes for their classmates without SEN, although these effects appear small.
Read all the results here: Kuhl, P., Kocaj, A., & Stanat, P. (2022). Relationships between inclusive education and cognitive and non-cognitive outcomes in children without special educational needs. Journal of Educational Psychology, 36(3), 1–26.
https://doi.org/10.1024/1010-0652/a000283
RĂĽdiger, Jansen, and Rjosk (2021) used data from the IQB-Bildungstrend 2015 to examine why boys receive lower grades in German than girls among ninth-graders, and whether these differences go beyond differences in competencies. Multilevel analyses confirmed that boys had lower German competencies and were also graded more poorly than girls with comparable abilities. Motivational characteristics proved relevant for grades, and there were indications of stereotypical teacher beliefs about students' reading motivation. Even after controlling for these variables, a gender effect remained, so the authors see further research potential on the topic.
You can find all of this here: Rüdiger, C., Jansen, M., & Rjosk, C. (2021). “Paul Isn’t Very Good at German.” Gender Differences in Grading in German—A Secondary Analysis of Data from the IQB Education Trends 2015. Psychology in Education and Instruction, 68. 10.2378/peu2021.art08d
Kretschmann, Westphal, and Vock (2021) used multilevel regressions on data from the IQB-Ländervergleich 2011 to examine whether age differences within classes affect fourth-graders' academic self-concept, peer relations, grades, and teacher recommendations for secondary school track placement. The data come from a two-stage sampling design in which schools were randomly selected and one class per school was surveyed, with family background, gender, and socioeconomic status included as covariates. Relative age had a significant effect on the outcomes, but only a very small one. The authors conclude that age-related differences between students may already have largely evened out by fourth grade.
For a more in-depth discussion of the results and their graphical representation, we recommend the full text of the article: Kretschmann, J., Westphal, A., & Vock, M. (2021). Does it pay to be one of the oldest in class? Relative age effects on academic self-concept, peer relations, and teacher judgments in German primary schools. Learning and Instruction, 74, 101463.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2021.101463
This 2018 study by Helbig and Morar asks whether Boudon’s model of primary and secondary origin effects needs to be extended by a tertiary effect, meaning socially unequal grading that is independent of students’ actual competencies. Using multilevel regressions on several datasets (BiKS 8-14, TIMSS 2011, IQB National Assessment Study 2011, and ELEMENT), they examined whether psychological traits such as effort explain why grades differ by socioeconomic background at the end of primary school. Students’ and parents’ self-assessments of these traits influenced grades but explained little of the grading bias. In contrast, teachers’ assessments of the same traits strongly affected grades and varied with family background, suggesting that teachers expect more favorable traits from children of highly educated parents and reward this in their grading, with an additional interaction between federal state and teachers’ perception of parental support.
For a detailed discussion of this effect and the other background information, findings, and implications, please refer to the full text of the article available below: Helbig, M. & Morar, T. (2018). Why Teachers Assign Socially Unequal Marks. A Case for Establishing Tertiary Origin Effects in the Model of Primary and Secondary Effects of Educational Research. International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 17(7), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.17.7.1
Kuschel, Richter, and Lazarides (2020) used teacher data from the IQB-Ländervergleich 2011 and 2012 as well as the IQB-Bildungstrend 2015 to examine whether legal requirements for teacher training attendance, and the obligation to document participation, actually lead teachers to attend more professional development. Linear and logistic regression models showed that legal requirements regarding the extent of training were associated with a higher number of courses attended. However, a specific training obligation increased the likelihood of participation in only one of the three studies. The article also looks at whether training participation differs between federal states with and without a documentation requirement.
You can read about which study found this correlation and whether there are differences in continuing education participation between federal states that require proof of participation in continuing education in this article: Kuschel, J., Richter, D., & Lazarides, R. (2020). How relevant is the legal requirement for continuing education for teachers? An empirical study on continuing education participation in various German federal states. Journal of Educational Research, 10(2), 211–229. https://doi.org/10.1007/s35834-020-00274-3
Roller and Steinberg (2020) examined whether an earlier transition from primary to secondary school is linked to differences in ninth-graders' reading comprehension. They exploited a school reform that moved the tracking of students into Gymnasium, Realschule, and Hauptschule from after sixth grade to after fourth grade, and applied a differences-in-differences approach to data from the PISA studies and the IQB-Ländervergleich 2008/09, comparing cohorts before and after the reform with a control group not affected by it. On average, earlier tracking was not meaningfully related to students' achievement. However, higher-achieving students who moved on to a Gymnasium benefited from the earlier transition, while lower-achieving students performed worse in reading comprehension on average.
You can read more about the findings here: Roller, M. & Steinberg, D. (2020). The distributional effects of early school stratification—non-parametric evidence from Germany. European Economic Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euroecorev.2020.103422
Richter, Richter, and Marx (2018) used teacher data from the IQB-Ländervergleich 2012 to examine which barriers keep lower secondary teachers in Germany from participating in professional development. They also tested whether non-participating teachers differ systematically from those who attend regularly. Group comparisons using analysis of variance revealed significant differences by gender and professional experience: female teachers and those with less experience were more likely to take part in training than male teachers and those with more experience. The article additionally looks at which reasons for non-participation teachers reported and how these relate to their training activity.
You can read about the reasons reported for non-participation and the extent to which these are related to teachers’ professional development activities in the article below: Richter, E., Richter, D., & Marx, A. (2018). What prevents teachers from participating in professional development? An empirical study of participation barriers among lower secondary school teachers in Germany. Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft, 21, 1021–1043.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11618-018-0820-4
Mok and colleagues (2016) used data from the IQB-Ländervergleich 2008/2009 to examine how the proportion of Turkish-origin students in a class relates to students' reading competence and sense of belonging at school. They found that Turkish-origin students, but not German-origin students, reported a higher sense of belonging in classes with a higher share of Turkish-origin classmates. The article also looks at how the share of Turkish-origin students is related to reading performance.
To learn how the percent of students of Turkish origin relates to reading skills, see the publication cited below: Mok, S. Y., Martiny, S. E., Gleibs, I. H., Keller, M. M., & Froehlich, L. (2016). The relationship between ethnic classroom composition and Turkish-origin and German students’ reading performance and sense of belonging. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 1071. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.01071
KuL: Competence Acquisition and Learning Preconditions đź”—
Harms, Gentrup, Schotte, Weirich, Dumont, and Edele examine whether school disciplinary processes may be linked to origin-based inequalities, asking whether teachers perceive, evaluate, or sanction comparable classroom situations differently depending on which students are shown. They use the video-based design of the KuL study ("Kompetenzerwerb und Lernvoraussetzungen"), in which teachers assessed classroom situations, to test whether judgments of student behavior and responses to rule violations systematically vary with student characteristics. The publication in Learning and Instruction is a Registered Report (Stage I), meaning that research questions, hypotheses, design, and analysis plan were peer-reviewed before the main analyses were run, so no results are available yet. This format strengthens transparency and ensures that the quality of the study is judged independently of its eventual findings.
You can find the article here: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2026.102362
Hürlimann, Lüdtke, and Schmerse (2025) used integrative data analysis of six German longitudinal studies, covering over 15,000 children in more than 2,500 preschool and primary school classes, to examine whether a group’s average language skills influence individual children’s language development. Identical multilevel models were estimated for each study and then combined meta-analytically, allowing for a systematic check of differences between studies. There was no general main effect, meaning children overall did not benefit from learning alongside linguistically stronger peers. However, children with lower initial language skills benefited clearly more, while those with average or high skills showed no effect, pointing to compensatory effects. The authors conclude that purposefully composed learning groups could help reduce language disparities, and that integrative analyses across studies offer great potential for secondary research.
You can find the full article here: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2026-54793-001
LISA: Educational Outcomes of Students from Vocational and Academic Upper Secondary Schools đź”—
Friedrich and SchĂĽtz (2023) examined whether conscientiousness can compensate for lower intelligence in predicting school grades, using secondary data from LISA 6 with 3,775 twelfth- and thirteenth-grade students from vocational and academic upper secondary schools in Schleswig-Holstein (2012/2013).
Using latent moderation analyses and multigroup models to check for gender differences, they found that both intelligence and conscientiousness positively predicted grades in biology, mathematics, and German.
Conscientiousness also moderated the relationship between intelligence and grades, with no significant interaction in English.
The authors conclude that schools should foster not only cognitive abilities but also traits such as self-organization and goal orientation.
For more exciting details, we recommend reading the full text of the study:
https://doi.org/10.3390/jintelligence11070146
PHONO: Short- and Long-term Effects of a Phonological Awareness Training Program for Kindergarteners With and Without German Home Language đź”—
Hürlimann, Lüdtke, and Schmerse (2025) used integrative data analysis of six German longitudinal studies, covering over 15,000 children in more than 2,500 preschool and primary school classes, to examine whether a group’s average language skills influence individual children’s language development. Identical multilevel models were estimated for each study and then combined meta-analytically, allowing for a systematic check of differences between studies. There was no general main effect, meaning children overall did not benefit from learning alongside linguistically stronger peers. However, children with lower initial language skills benefited clearly more, while those with average or high skills showed no effect, pointing to compensatory effects. The authors conclude that purposefully composed learning groups could help reduce language disparities, and that integrative analyses across studies offer great potential for secondary research.
You can find the full article here: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2026-54793-001
PISA: Programme for International Student Assessment đź”—
Heppt, Schwarzenthal, and Scharf (2025) used PISA 2018 data from 2,947 students in Germany, mostly in ninth grade, to examine how a perceived discriminatory school climate, such as teachers making derogatory remarks about certain cultural groups, relates to school adjustment, and whether teaching quality mediates this link. A more strongly perceived discriminatory climate was associated with lower reading competence, lower reading motivation, and a weaker sense of belonging at school. Students with backgrounds in Turkey, the SWANA region, or sub-Saharan Africa perceived the climate as more discriminatory than other groups did. A discriminatory climate was also linked to poorer classroom management, which in turn may have negative effects on achievement and sense of belonging, underscoring the importance of a respectful, inclusive school climate and high-quality teaching. You can find the full article here: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-025-02147-2
Ostermann and Neugebauer (2021) asked whether similarity in social background between students and teachers can help reduce educational inequalities. Using propensity score matching and longitudinal data from PISA-I-Plus 2003-2004, they compared students from low and high socioeconomic backgrounds who were taught by teachers with a similar social background to those whose teachers were socially less similar. Contrary to one reading of Bourdieu's habitus concept, similarity made no difference: students benefited neither in perceived support, nor in competence development, nor in grades from being taught and assessed by socially similar teachers. However, the authors found a negative effect of teachers' social background on students' perceived support that was independent of the students' own socioeconomic status.
For a detailed discussion of the theoretical background, different operationalizations, and the results and implications, we recommend reading the full text of the article (which, incidentally, is published under open access): Ostermann, C. & Neugebauer, M. (2021). Does Similarity Make a Difference? When Socioeconomically Disadvantaged Students Are Taught by Socially Similar Teachers. KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für Soziologie und Sozialpsychologie, 1–25. DOI: 10.1007/s11577-021-00779-3.
Roller and Steinberg (2020) examined whether an earlier transition from primary to secondary school is linked to differences in ninth-graders' reading comprehension. They exploited a school reform that moved the tracking of students into Gymnasium, Realschule, and Hauptschule from after sixth grade to after fourth grade, and applied a differences-in-differences approach to data from the PISA studies and the IQB-Ländervergleich 2008/09, comparing cohorts before and after the reform with a control group not affected by it. On average, earlier tracking was not meaningfully related to students' achievement. However, higher-achieving students who moved on to a Gymnasium benefited from the earlier transition, while lower-achieving students performed worse in reading comprehension on average.
You can read more about the findings here: Roller, M. & Steinberg, D. (2020). The distributional effects of early school stratification—non-parametric evidence from Germany. European Economic Review. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euroecorev.2020.103422
Atlay, Tieben, Hillmert, and Fauth (2019) used longitudinal data from PISA-I-Plus 2003/2004 to examine how perceived instructional quality (cognitive activation, classroom management, and supportive learning climate) relates to students' math achievement, focusing on whether effects differ by parental education (ISCED). Multilevel analyses showed an overall positive association between classroom management and math achievement. For cognitive activation and supportive learning climate, the effects differed for students with high parental education compared to those with medium or low parental education. The article also explores the direction of these differential effects and how the two instructional dimensions moderate social disparities in achievement.
You can read more about the direction of these differential effects and how these two dimensions of instruction moderate social disparities in skill acquisition here: Atlay, C., Tieben, N., Hillmert, S., & Fauth, B. (2019). Instructional quality and achievement inequality: How effective is teaching in closing the social achievement gap? Learning and Instruction, 63, 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2019.05.008
Lazarides and Buchholz (2019) used longitudinal data from the PISA-I-Plus study (2003/2004) to examine how student-perceived teaching quality in math classes relates to different achievement emotions in ninth and tenth grade. Using multilevel analyses, they found, for example, that high perceived teacher support in ninth grade was associated with lower levels of boredom and anxiety in tenth grade. The article also looks at how perceived teaching quality relates to enjoyment of learning, along with further findings.
You can read about the relationship between perceived teaching quality and enjoyment of learning, as well as the authors’ other findings, in the article below: Lazarides, R. & Buchholz, J. (2019). Student-perceived teaching quality: How is it related to different achievement emotions in mathematics classrooms? Learning and Instruction, 61, 45–59. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2019.01.001
SEIKA: Language Education and Development in Kindergarten in North Rhine-Westphalia đź”—
Hürlimann, Lüdtke, and Schmerse (2025) used integrative data analysis of six German longitudinal studies, covering over 15,000 children in more than 2,500 preschool and primary school classes, to examine whether a group’s average language skills influence individual children’s language development. Identical multilevel models were estimated for each study and then combined meta-analytically, allowing for a systematic check of differences between studies. There was no general main effect, meaning children overall did not benefit from learning alongside linguistically stronger peers. However, children with lower initial language skills benefited clearly more, while those with average or high skills showed no effect, pointing to compensatory effects. The authors conclude that purposefully composed learning groups could help reduce language disparities, and that integrative analyses across studies offer great potential for secondary research.
You can find the full article here: https://psycnet.apa.org/record/2026-54793-001
StEG: Study on the Development of All-Day Schools đź”—
Busching and Krahé (2018) used longitudinal data from 16,891 adolescents in 1,308 classes at 252 all-day schools (StEG 2005-2009) to examine whether deviant behavior is "contagious" within school classes, rather than only within friendship groups. Using multilevel analyses with two measurement points, they looked at both the average level and the variance of deviant behavior in a class, as well as cross-level interactions. Adolescents who already showed deviant behavior at the first time point did so more often at the second, and this increase was stronger in classes where deviant behavior was widespread (low variance) than in classes where only a few students behaved very deviantly. The effect was stronger for boys than for girls, and the authors explain it by deviant behavior becoming a norm in such classes, concluding that it should be recognized and addressed as early as possible.
For more exciting details, we recommend reading the full text of the study:
https://doi.org/10.1177/1948550617725151
Busching and Krahé (2020) conducted a secondary analysis of the StEG study (2005-2009) to examine how the average level of prosocial behavior among classmates influences the development of an individual adolescent's prosocial behavior. Using multilevel analyses in R, they also tested whether the effects of class composition differ between girls and boys or depend on students' initial level of prosocial behavior. Adolescents in classes with a high collective level of prosocial behavior reported more prosocial behavior about two years later. Adolescents with low self-reported prosocial behavior at the first time point benefited especially from such a positive class composition, and the article further examines whether gender moderates these associations.
You can read about the extent to which students’ gender moderates these relationships in this article, which also catches the eye with its engaging title: Busching, R. & Krahé, B. (2020). With a little help from their peers: The impact of classmates on adolescents’ development of prosocial behavior. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 49, 1849–1863.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-020-01260-8
TIMSS: Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study đź”—
This study by Helbig and Morar (2018) asks whether Boudon’s model of primary and secondary origin effects needs to be extended by a tertiary effect, meaning socially unequal grading that is independent of students’ actual competencies. Using multilevel regressions on several datasets (BiKS 8-14, TIMSS 2011, IQB National Assessment Study 2011, and ELEMENT), they examined whether psychological traits such as effort explain why grades differ by socioeconomic background at the end of primary school. Students’ and parents’ self-assessments of these traits influenced grades but explained little of the grading bias. In contrast, teachers’ assessments of the same traits strongly affected grades and varied with family background, suggesting that teachers expect more favorable traits from children of highly educated parents and reward this in their grading, with an additional interaction between federal state and teachers’ perception of parental support.
You can find a detailed discussion of this effect and the other background information, findings, and implications in the full text of the article: Helbig, M. & Morar, T. (2018). Why Teachers Assign Socially Unequal Marks. A Case for Establishing Tertiary Origin Effects in the Model of Primary and Secondary Effects of Educational Research. International Journal of Learning, Teaching and Educational Research, 17(7), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.26803/ijlter.17.7.1
RĂĽdiger, Jansen, and Kocaj examined how teacher-rated work and social behavior influence the subject grades of primary school children, and what role gender plays. Using secondary data from IGLU 2016 and TIMSS 2015, they tested whether teachers rate girls' and boys' behavior differently and whether these ratings affect grades in German and math, even when controlling for competencies. Girls' work and social behavior were consistently rated more positively, but only work behavior, not social behavior, influenced grades. Work behavior ratings mediated part of the gender differences in grades, fully in German and partially in math, showing how general behavioral judgments can spill over into subject-specific assessments.
You can find the full article here:
https://econtent.hogrefe.com/doi/10.1024/1010-0652/a000401
Image sources in order of appearance on the page, from left to right and from top to bottom; attribution according to the guidelines of the authors/image databases.
- Copyright 2025 Katerina Limpitsouni via undraw.co